Why historic oil reserves release may do little to bring down rising prices – Al Jazeera

Lead

The International Energy Agency (IEA) announced on Wednesday a historic coordinated release of 400 million barrels of strategic oil reserves to stabilise markets after the escalation of the United States–Israel war with Iran. Global benchmarks jumped immediately—the Brent price rose roughly 15% after the announcement—and traded near $100 a barrel as of 02:00 GMT on Thursday. Analysts say the move can provide short-term relief but is unlikely to bring prices down materially if the Strait of Hormuz remains effectively closed, because the closure already removed roughly one-fifth of global daily flows. Market participants warn that the supply gap created over the first 12 days of the conflict—an estimated shortfall exceeding 200 million barrels—already consumes more than half of the IEA’s planned release.

Key Takeaways

  • The IEA announced a coordinated release of about 400 million barrels of emergency oil stocks on Wednesday to calm markets after attacks tied to the US–Israel war with Iran.
  • Brent crude climbed about 15% immediately after the IEA statement and traded near $100 a barrel at 02:00 GMT on Thursday, roughly 35% above pre-war levels.
  • About 20 million barrels per day normally transit the Strait of Hormuz; analysts estimate the current effective halt accounts for roughly 20% of global supply.
  • After 12 days of conflict the cumulative global shortfall is estimated to exceed 200 million barrels—more than half of the IEA’s planned release.
  • Individual member contributions will vary: the US plans to release 172 million barrels and Japan signalled it could release about 80 million, but the IEA gave no firm timeline for deliveries.
  • JPMorgan estimates IEA members could raise output by roughly 1.2 million barrels per day at most—far below normal daily flows through the strait.
  • Past coordinated releases had mixed results: a 60 million-barrel release in 2022 coincided with a near-term price spike, while 1991 releases aided a rapid market correction.

Background

The Strait of Hormuz, a narrow chokepoint bordered by Iran, Oman and the United Arab Emirates, ordinarily carries about 20 million barrels of oil per day—roughly one-fifth of global seaborne crude. In early March 2026, Tehran issued explicit threats to shipping after hostilities expanded following actions involving the United States and Israel, and state-linked forces reported blocking transits. That escalation coincided with multiple attacks on commercial vessels: on Wednesday at least five ships were struck in the region, including two oil tankers in Iraq’s port of al-Faw.

The IEA coordinates the collective release of strategic stockpiles held by its 32 member countries; the total coordinated stockpile base is about 1.8 billion barrels, but those reserves are owned and managed by individual states. Historically the agency has mobilised emergency releases on several occasions with varied outcomes. In 2022, a 60 million-barrel release followed Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and market prices initially jumped before easing; by contrast, coordinated releases around the 1991 Gulf War are credited with helping bring rapid price relief once combat operations began.

Main Event

On Wednesday the Paris-based IEA said it would coordinate the release of roughly 400 million barrels of oil from member country reserves to help stabilise markets. The announcement prompted an immediate market reaction: Brent futures rose about 15% that day. Officials emphasised the release was unprecedented in scale, but the agency did not specify an exact schedule for deliveries, saying further details would follow.

Major producers moved to outline their shares of the release. The US Department of Energy said it would begin releasing its allocated 172 million barrels next week, while Japan’s prime minister, Sanae Takaichi, announced plans to make about 80 million barrels available as early as Monday. The mechanics differ across countries because strategic stocks are physically dispersed and must be drawn down, transported and blended to reach markets—steps that take time.

Market dynamics have been turbulent in the days before and after the IEA decision. Brent spiked to about $119 on Monday, then plunged below $80 on Tuesday after a false claim by US Energy Secretary Chris Wright that the US Navy had escorted a tanker through the strait. Traders remain sensitive to expectations; several analysts said the IEA move may already be priced into current levels and that sustained disruptions could push prices much higher once the buffer is consumed.

Analysis & Implications

The release is large by historical standards, but it addresses a stock problem, not the physical bottleneck that currently prevents roughly 20 million barrels per day from transiting the Strait of Hormuz. If the waterway remains effectively closed, the 400 million-barrel release will smooth short-term liquidity but cannot replace sustained daily flows. That gap—measured in millions of barrels per day—requires either rapid increased output from other producers or a swift re-opening of the strait to shipping.

Market models show that temporary injections of supply can moderate volatility for a period, particularly if they change trader expectations about near-term availability. However, once reserves are drawn down they reduce the system’s ability to respond to further shocks. Gregor Semieniuk of the University of Massachusetts Amherst warns that the release could simply postpone price pressure: if the strait closure persists beyond this week, prices may surge again as the strategic buffer is exhausted.

There are logistical and political constraints on raising immediate replacement supply. JPMorgan’s past-analysis-based estimate that member countries could add up to 1.2 million barrels per day is modest compared with the strait’s normal throughput; bringing that extra output online faces lead times for production increases, regulatory approvals, and shipping capacity. Those frictions mean that, absent de-escalation, global markets are likely to remain on edge and price spikes remain possible.

Comparison & Data

Item Quantity
IEA planned release ~400 million barrels
US announced share 172 million barrels
Japan signalled share ~80 million barrels
Normal flow via Strait of Hormuz ~20 million barrels/day
Estimated shortfall after 12 days >200 million barrels
Estimated member output boost (JPMorgan) ~1.2 million barrels/day

The table underlines the scale mismatch: the IEA release is large in aggregate but, measured against daily flows and the cumulative shortfall that developed in less than two weeks, it amounts to a temporary buffer rather than a sustainable replacement. Supply injections are also lumpy—missing a single day of transit removes raw volumes that are difficult to replenish quickly.

Reactions & Quotes

Officials, industry figures and analysts offered cautious assessments that combined appreciation for the IEA action with scepticism about its long-term impact.

“It’s not a silver bullet to solve everything; you have to solve the underlying problem of transit through the strait.”

Maksim Sonin, Stanford Center for Fuels of the Future (energy executive)

Sonin framed the release as a useful but limited tool: markets trade on expectations, and until shipping risk recedes traders will remain concerned.

“If this continues, the release will only buy temporary relief.”

Gregor Semieniuk, University of Massachusetts Amherst (public policy & economics)

Semieniuk emphasised that once strategic stocks are drawn down, the market’s vulnerability to further supply shocks increases, potentially magnifying future price moves.

“If the roughly 400 million barrels being discussed convinces traders supply can meet near-term demand, it can calm prices for a while—but disruption persistence changes the calculation.”

Chad Norville, Rigzone (industry publication president)

Unconfirmed

  • The IRGC’s prediction that oil will reach $200 a barrel is a projection and not a consensus forecast; such spikes would depend on the duration and depth of the strait’s closure and market reactions.
  • The precise timetable for when and how much of the 400 million barrels will physically reach markets remains unspecified by the IEA; delivery schedules from member states are still being finalised.
  • Claims that the strait is permanently closed are not independently verified; reports indicate an effective halt to most traffic but not a formal legal closure recognised by all parties.

Bottom Line

The IEA’s 400 million-barrel coordinated release is historically large and will likely temper price volatility in the very near term, especially if it reassures traders about short-term availability. But it is not a structural fix: strategic stocks are finite and cannot substitute for the continuous daily flows that the Strait of Hormuz historically delivered.

If the maritime disruption persists, markets will focus on how quickly alternative supply can be ramped and whether demand-side adjustments occur. For policymakers and market participants, the critical watch points are the duration of the strait’s effective closure, the speed at which member country releases reach refineries, and any further escalation that could deepen the physical supply shortfall.

Sources

Leave a Comment